Does It Matter if Your Moderator Is From Venus or Mars?

by | Jan 12, 2015 | Uncategorized

The fact that selecting the right moderator for a market research campaign is of the utmost importance is nothing new. In fact, some believe that this is one of the most important considerations when designing market research. However, lately I’ve been thinking more about what selecting the “right” moderator really means.

The market research that we do at Six Degrees is primarily in the health care space (pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, etc.). So most clients think of moderators in terms of overall experience, clinical expertise and style in determining whether he or she will be a good fit. In the past few months, though, it’s become increasingly apparent to me how differently respondents react to different, equally qualified moderators.

How to Select a Branding Agency: The Ultimate Guide

There are many situations when you may be considering how to select a branding agency. Some of the more common situations include launching a new bran...

Read more

Recently, we concluded two studies with very similar constituents: male patients, generally in a relatively young demographic, as well as mothers (caregivers) of children with a particular medical condition. Each study was moderated by an experienced and knowledgeable moderator on the subject matter in question. The key difference: one male moderator and one female moderator.

As I listened to these interviews, we joked in the office that the male moderator was the most likely to have participants use extremely NSFW (not suitable for work) language in their interviews, while the female moderator was most likely to have a mother cry on the phone with her. While we spoke about this lightly, it represents a very true and real issue that needs to be considered – namely, how well your participants will connect with the moderator on a personal, more social level. While the feedback that each moderator received was extremely valuable, it begs the question of how the gender of the moderator colors the research results.

In another example that came up recently, we showed creative concepts for a drug to physicians. One of the concepts included a female as the focal point. A number of male physicians remarked specifically about her looks, saying that she wasn’t pretty enough, or they would prefer to see a model in the picture who was “a bit less chubby.” I think you can probably guess the gender of the moderator with whom they shared these opinions. Again, these are valuable insights in that they reveal what the target audience of the concepts really thinks. I wonder how likely it is that these comments would have been brought to light with a female moderator.

Six Degrees has also conducted research with males about an erectile dysfunction medication using a female moderator. She opened up the interviews by sharing something personal, and letting the participants know that “nothing you say here today is going to shock me.” Using an approach like this, the men were willing to open up about very personal issues, and the research that we did was used to help launch an extremely successful product.

Overall, selecting the right moderator to fit a project is something of an art. One must consider experience, subject knowledge, personality and interview design in such a way that you can elicit honest, true responses in a comfortable setting. By assembling a diverse team of moderators with extremely varied skill sets and backgrounds, we are able to tailor research approaches to fit with a range of objectives, no matter how sensitive the material may be for consumers or how clinical for health care professionals.

  • Select category:

Want to publish a
guest post?

Review Guidelines
Subscribe today to get our latest content delivered to your inbox
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Follow us

Christopher Nagle
Chris has more than 20 years of design and art direction experience with work that spans multiple industries and areas of application. His drive to uncover what sparks the motivations of his target audiences is what has led to a career of not only award-winning work, but work that moves the needle for his clients. Chris’ extensive background working with researchers and strategists has also given him a strong understanding of how to ensure that visual communications are true to the brand while reaching the right audience in the intended manner.

Ready to talk?

Learn more about us • Get some case studies • Schedule a presentation • Scope a project